Penalty Killing Poll

Moderator: SharksGM

Should defensemen be allowed to play forward on the penalty kill?

Poll ended at Sat Feb 23, 2013 11:45 pm

Yes
7
37%
No
12
63%
 
Total votes: 19

CapsGM

Re: Penalty Killing Poll

Post by CapsGM »

Commissioner (CBJ) wrote:
CapsGM wrote:The rulebook should clarify any exceptions to the rule, as there's plenty of confusion about it.
Hey, I tried to cover everything. I didn't realize we were going to devolve into an a bunch of school-aged children who tattle on each other.
Image
Penguin

Re: Penalty Killing Poll

Post by Penguin »

I know where you're coming from Quinny but it never happened that my coach decided to use 3 Ds since I've been playing as a little novice! If it did happen the other day though for the Avs, then I don't know what to say! What's the final verdict?
Jungle Cats

Re: Penalty Killing Poll

Post by Jungle Cats »

Joe Sacco is a terrible coach?
User avatar
GM Office Q
Posts: 932
Joined: Fri Sep 18, 2009 7:59 pm

Re: Penalty Killing Poll

Post by GM Office Q »

Jungle Cats wrote:Joe Sacco is a terrible coach?
This.
CapsGM

Re: Penalty Killing Poll

Post by CapsGM »

Sadly, there's worse defenders than Hunsuck.

User avatar
Virtual Jarmo
Posts: 8716
Joined: Fri Sep 18, 2009 5:43 pm
Location: Cleveland, OH
Contact:

Re: Penalty Killing Poll

Post by Virtual Jarmo »

AvsGM wrote:
Jungle Cats wrote:Joe Sacco is a terrible coach?
This.
Nice rush by Hunwick last night on the Jones game winner.

I wasn't a big fan of Sacco when he was coaching the Monsters. FWIW, I don't like Chynoweth either, but, in his defense, the injuries in Colorado have really ravaged the Monsters ever since the NHL came back.
Adam Burke
Former Commissioner, Current Jackets GM and Owner of Eastside's Hockey Elite Collide
Jungle Cats

Re: Penalty Killing Poll

Post by Jungle Cats »

Eh, Breeze-bye on his last legs was about as good as Hunwick. Bigger, somewhat productive, at least.

Ryan O'Byrne though. Yikes.
Montreal Canadiens

Re: Penalty Killing Poll

Post by Montreal Canadiens »

OTT still has Jared Cowen on the F spot in his PK, although he's suspended for the next game, but after that, can't go back there.
Calgary.Flames

Re: Penalty Killing Poll

Post by Calgary.Flames »

This issue has only been discussed. There's still no rule regarding this as of today.
Unless the league officially says so, this is not yet a rule.
User avatar
Virtual Jarmo
Posts: 8716
Joined: Fri Sep 18, 2009 5:43 pm
Location: Cleveland, OH
Contact:

Re: Penalty Killing Poll

Post by Virtual Jarmo »

Calgary.Flames wrote:This issue has only been discussed. There's still no rule regarding this as of today.
Unless the league officially says so, this is not yet a rule.
Commissioner (CBJ) wrote:One choice: Yes or No.

Poll ends Friday at 10:45 p.m. EST. Starting Friday, that will be our rule on defensemen playing forward on the PK.
First post of the thread. Majority rule won, 19-7, so defensemen cannot play forward on the PK.
Adam Burke
Former Commissioner, Current Jackets GM and Owner of Eastside's Hockey Elite Collide
Post Reply

Return to “GM Memos and General Chatter”